Cardboard and Sisal Cat Scratcher Reviews (Tried and Tested)
- Rachel
- Aug 23
- 7 min read
Updated: Nov 18
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you.
All photos are my own and previously unpublished. I am not affiliated with any of the companies mentioned in this article or being paid to promote their products.
In my previous post, Why Do Cats Scratch and How to Stop It?, we looked at some of the reasons why kitty might be pulling up your carpets and tearing stuffing out of your sofa. Scratching is a natural behaviour but can become destructive if cats aren't given the resources to sharpen and maintain their claws. Scratching also provides exercise, enrichment and the opportunity to scent mark.
A variety of fun and engaging scratchers is essential to keep cats happy and protect your home furnishings, so let's dive into some tried and tested options to suit every cat.
Cat Scratchers:
;
These scratcher baskets are typically available in small, medium and large sizes with a choice of oval or round styles. They're made from high-density corrugated cardboard with a textured surface and raised edges for cats to nap and rest in. Since cats like to scratch after waking up, it's an ideal solution.
These are both of my boys' favourite type of scratcher, although Simba can't resist the carpet on occasion! The thickened card is sturdy enough to hold a human's weight, but some owners find that they don't withstand scratching for longer than a couple of weeks. By contrast, mine have lasted over a year but it depends on your kitty's enthusiasm levels.
The baskets are fairly inexpensive depending on where you shop and what size you require. Be sure to check measurements before purchasing as a lot of customers find that they're smaller than they appear in photos - if anything, I'd suggest sizing up.
They also have a tendency to flip over due to the edges being wider than the base, which might be funny for you but no so much for kitty! Due to the material and texture, they're not the easiest to clean.
Overall, most cats seem to love these baskets. Worst-case scenario, if you have multiple kitties then you might find yourself investing in a few more to prevent squabbling!
Sizes vary. The baskets pictured are extra large:
Oval 58cm (l) x 42cm (w)
Round 55cm x 55cm
This 3-in-1 scratch board and lounger is constructed from solid wood and recycled corrugated cardboard. The wooden frame protects the edges of the scratcher for extra resilience, while adding a bit of height which my cats love.
Some assembly is required, but you can choose from three different scratching angles by altering the leg positions: flat, 40° and 70° (almost vertical). When used flat it can double up as a bed or resting spot, with a curved design that's suited to a cat's delicate spine.
The overall product is sturdy, well constructed and long lasting, with positive feedback from customers. The only issue I've found is that it's easy to flip over if kitty puts its weight on either end (kind of like a seesaw) which has led to a few scares!
Sizes vary.
The scratch board pictured is medium: 49cm (l) x 29cm (w).
This cat hammock is crafted from a solid wooden frame and natural sisal pad that's durable and fray resistant. It has a curved design for a comfortable sleeping position and comes in various lengths so cats can stretch their bodies.
The scratcher is easy to assemble with a modern design that blends in nicely with home living spaces. Since it's built like a hammock, the material has some give which might put cats off as they prefer to have solid footing. It's easy to clean by removing the sisal mat for washing.
Customers appreciate the scratcher as a practical solution for claw maintenance without the shedding you get with cardboard. However, some cats prefer it as a bed which could be due to the movement when scratching. It's not the sturdiest of structures, especially if you have heavier cats - mine haven't used it at all.
Sizes vary.
The hammock pictured is 50cm (l) x 32cm (w).
A cosy cat sofa that combines lounging and scratching with soft plush and a durable sisal pad. The sofa is a good size, with plenty of length for stretching and a raised back for comfort. It's built with anti-slip feet that give it a small elevation off ground level.
I really love this sleek little sofa; it's durable and weighty and looks great in the living room. Unfortunately my cats have completely ignored it, which is a shame given that it's a slightly more expensive option. If your cat likes sisal then this is a worthy purchase, but mine seem to prefer cardboard.
Overall size: 61cm (l) x 38cm (w)
This multi-functional cat bed is crafted from natural sisal to provide a texture that cats are inclined to scratch, while being comfortable and durable. It has an anti-slip base and foamboard padding, which makes it lightweight and a tad spongey.
The scratcher doubles up as a cosy bed with a dipped centre - I almost want to take a nap on it myself. The cute design isn't an eyesore in the home and it's suitable for cats of all ages and sizes. It comes with an attached ball for extra engagement, prompting kitty to use its claws.
Customers love the cute design and spacious size, but some cats don't like standing on it due to the foam being a little soft. Even if it's not used as a scratcher, it has the advantage of making a great bed and toy.
Overall size: 61cm (l) x 40cm (w)
This stylish scratcher is purrfect for the pampered puss while complementing your home decor. It's made completely from cardboard to satisfy your cat's urge to sharpen their claws, and the elevated position entices them to sit and lounge on their own piece of furniture - giving them less need to scratch yours!
Admittedly, I bought this for the cool design but also because my cats love their cardboard baskets; although it's less used, which is a shame given that it's double the price. The PawHut Lounger comes in several designs if you shop around, and the free catnip is a bonus.
Customers love that the scratcher matches their decor, say it's good value for money and lasts longer than standard boards. They're spacious enough for most adult cats but larger breeds might be a squeeze.
Overall size: 60cm (l) x 29cm (w) x 26.5cm (h)
Seat: 33.5 (l) x 26cm (w)
Off the ground: 12.3cm
This unique design by PAWZ Road is constructed from BC and BB corrugated card for enhanced firmness and durability. It offers three pose positions to adapt to cats' different scratching angles and can be placed horizontally or vertically, making good use of household spaces.
Additionally, the multi-functional scratcher combines claw sharpening with sleeping and playing. Cats can use it as a lounge spot, bat the ball nestled in the recess or play hide-and-seek in the hole. Since the middle block can be removed from the slot, you're getting an extra scratcher for free.
I initially placed a couple of these in the hall when my cats went through their aggressive phase, hoping it'd provide a distraction from glaring at each other. It helped somewhat with Drax, but Simba completely ignored them - and I don't think they've ever noticed the ball, but that's my boys all over!
Customers appreciate the product's large size and sturdiness, and cats can make use of the 3-sided scratching board by turning it around when one side is worn. It also makes a great ramp for senior cats and kittens that need help climbing onto higher surfaces like sofas. As with all cardboard scratchers, try to keep it clean and dry.
Overall size: 31cm (h) x 71cm (w) x 19cm (d)
Cats love a good box, and the Conlun Scratching Box has multiple uses. It provides a secure, enclosed space for resting, with two side holes for swatting toys and playmates. The scratcher can be placed inside as a base or used separately, and it's made from high-density recycled cardboard which is reversible for extended use.
The great thing about these boxes is that they trap loose shavings to keep floors clean, reducing the need for constant sweeping. Many owners find this engaging enough to deter cats from scratching furniture but, as always, double check the measurements as adult cats may need a larger size.
As well as sizing, boxes come in a few different colours and designs, with extra scratch boards or additional cat toys. Despite this being a versatile product, some customers complain about it being expensive for what it is, especially as you could make your own version at home.
To save a few pennies, check out this how-to guide: DIY Cat Toys That Are Cheap and Easy to Make: Step-by-Step Guides
Sizes vary.
The box pictured is large: 43.2cm (l) x 25cm (w) x 12.7cm (h).
The Skylos Scratcher House has three sides of high-density recycled corrugated cardboard with a front and back made from solid wood, including a doorway and peepholes. Cats can lounge on the top or nap inside, with multiple surfaces for scratching and territory marking. It also comes with a removable spring mouse toy for batting and swatting.
The house can be tucked away in a corner and easily blends in with the home; however, it's quite compact inside. Drax is 5kg and barely squeezes into it, while Simba has never made the attempt!
Customers find it easy to assemble, great for kittens but too small for large adult cats.
Overall size: 30cm (h) x 40cm (w) x 30cm (d)
In summary, cardboard and sisal scratchers are great alternatives to standard posts, especially for cats that prefer to scratch horizontally. Cardboard typically has more shedding and may not last as long, but cats are attracted to the texture; while sisal can better withstand excessive scratching and provides a deterrent from your carpets.
Those with incorporated toys offer extra enrichment, while baskets and loungers are multi-functional for smaller living spaces. There are lots of options and styles available, and these are just a few examples to get you started.
Hopefully, I've given you some ideas for adding a bit of fun and variety to the home - and more importantly, kitty's environment. Happy shopping!
Information accurate from August 2025 and may be subject to change. Feel free to get in touch if you think this article needs updating.
Do you have any of these scratchers at home or something similar? Share your buys and inspo for other pet parents.
